IND vs AUS 4th Test: Why Was Yashasvi Jaiswal Given Out Despite Nothing on Snicko?
In the fourth Test between India and Australia at the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG), a controversial moment unfolded when Indian opener Yashasvi Jaiswal was declared caught behind, despite the Snickometer (Snicko) showing no clear spike. This contentious decision has reignited debates over the use of technology in cricket.
The Incident:
Facing a short-pitched delivery from Australian skipper Pat Cummins, Jaiswal attempted a pull shot. The Australians confidently appealed for a catch behind, claiming Jaiswal had edged the ball. However, the on-field umpire remained unmoved and gave the batter not out. Convinced of an edge, Cummins immediately opted for a review.
Technological Analysis:
The Decision Review System (DRS) relies heavily on tools like the Snickometer (Snicko), which measures sound frequencies to detect possible edges. In Jaiswal’s case, Snicko surprisingly showed no noticeable spike as the ball passed the bat. Despite this, the third umpire, Sharfuddoula, decided to overturn the on-field decision.
The Decision:
Sharfuddoula concluded that there was sufficient evidence to rule Jaiswal out, citing other indications of contact between the bat and ball, even though Snicko did not register a spike. This decision overturned the on-field umpire’s original call of not out.
Understanding the Controversy:
This incident highlights the challenges in balancing technology and human judgment in cricket:
- Reliability of Technology: When one tool, like Snicko, doesn’t provide clear evidence, the decision can still hinge on other factors.
- Overturning Decisions: The third umpire ruled in favor of the bowler, leading to a debatable overturn of the on-field umpire’s decision.
Conclusion:
Yashasvi Jaiswal’s dismissal, stemming from a pull shot, has sparked renewed debates about the reliability and interplay of DRS tools. While technology aims to ensure fairness, moments like this underline the complexities of its application in cricket. The decision may have divided opinions, but it’s another reminder of the fine margins that make the game so compelling.
Read More: SA20 League – Teams, Venue & Schedule
